Determinants of the Arab National Security and Competition for Ethiopia By Waleed Zayed
Determinants of the Arab National Security and Competition for Ethiopia
By Waleed Zayed
Translated from Arabic by the Center for Arab Progress
The Horn of Africa is of strategic importance to the Arab world, especially to Egypt and the Gulf States. This region is considered to be the national security depth of the region, as well as its having a privileged location. Ethiopia is at the head of these countries. The country which was suffering from extreme poverty and threatened by starvation in 2000, has been able to leap major steps in the field of economic development and is considered one of the five fastest growing countries in the world. Ethiopia is seeking a position and influence in Africa, East Africa. Addis Ababa looks forward to encouraging foreign investment in all fields and in recent years has undertaken a series of radical reforms in the legal structure. It has launched a free market economy mechanism after decades of socialist restrictions.
In the context of the regional and international conflict in the region, including the internal Gulf dispute, Ethiopia has become a point of contention for conflicting interests. Further, it has become the main beneficiary of military, economic and security rivalries. Specifically, it is at the junction with a number of strategic files: security, water and African trade.
Protests and the turning point in the Ethiopian political system:
Ethiopia witnessed a wave of violent protests in February 2018, with a wave of popular protests against the policies of Haile Dessalin and his government, prompting him to resign. The dominant element in these violent demonstrations was the Arumu Muslim minority in protest against the policy of marginalization and deliberate lack of claims. Although they constitute about 40% of the country’s population. However, they are subject to the rule of the Tigray ethnic minority (only 6% of the population). They are deep in its control over the security, army and the basic state joints. The Government of the Tigray deliberately practiced unjust policies against Oromo and other nationalities. They exercised its right to persecution and marginalization, and deprived it of its political and economic rights. Over the past years, governments have been perpetuating poverty in the Oromo regions despite high levels of growth at other regions, with 80% of the poverty in these regions. Amnesty International has confirmed in its annual reports that the government is committing explicit violations of human rights against Oromo groups such as arbitrary arrests, enforced disappearances and extrajudicial detentions.
Human Rights Watch has condemned the deaths of more than 900 people in the protests in the Oromia region in 2015-2016 and the continued arrests of some 20,000 people.
In February 2018, however, the crisis was triggered by the government’s announcement of plans to expand the administrative scope of Addis Ababa at the expense of the Arumo and Amhara territories, which is rejected by the majority of the inhabitants of these areas. They considered it a means of changing the demographic structure in favor of Tigray; As a result of these protests, the Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF), which has ruled Ethiopia for 27 years, has taken some reform measures to calm the situation. The top of these reforms was the closure of political prisons and to allow the rise of populist figure Abi Ahmed as the new prime minister, replacing Hilary Mariam Desallin.
Abiy Ahmed is an ethnic Oromo, who has been leading the anti-government protests over the past three years since 2015. This is an important shift that can be built to dismantle the deep state, especially after he was able to sack the powerful figure in the regime. Little problems. In his first speech after his inauguration, Abe promised to hold accountable all those involved in the shooting and apologized for killing the demonstrators in the first precedent in the history of Ethiopian governments.
Abiy Ahmed and the transformation:
Since Abiy Ahmed took over the presidency of the Ethiopian government, he started a series of dynamic and non-traditional policies. These ambitious policies did not only aim at stability, economic development, and internal homogeneity, but also aimed at eliminating the deep state crisis. This crisis began in the 1990s with Eritrea’s independence, and becoming separate from the Red Sea coast and its official secession. This in return deprived Ethiopia of its maritime coasts. The policies also targeted at opening strategic corridors with neighboring countries, to form a network of long-term partnerships and to achieve some degree of economic integration.
The Ethiopian government held several agreements in which it obtained shares in important ports in East Africa (Somalia, Djibouti and Sudan) in order to break the sea isolation. On May 3, 2018, Ethiopia acquired a stake in Port Sudan, Sudan’s largest seaport on the Red Sea. It also obtained a stake in the port of Djibouti, which it relied on in its maritime trade and its interaction with the outside world. It benefited from Djibouti’s efforts to attract investment alternatives after the termination of the DP World (the world’s fourth largest port operator) concession.
Ethiopia is a strategic partner in the port of Berbera in Somaliland by 19%, in addition to its investment in the infrastructure necessary for the development of the port and the land routes leading to it. Ethiopia has also sought to create land routes for its foreign trade with neighboring African countries. Although these tracks were invested in before the arrival of Abiy Ahmed for years, it seeks to develop and invest in this strategy. In February 2018, the first international railway line In Africa opened, which operates on electricity, and connects Addis Ababa and the port of Djibouti, with a length of 750 km. It is also expected to complete a railway network linking it with Kenya, Sudan and Southern Sudan by 2020.
As for the conflict with Eritrea, the authority has become more open in this issue. It has decided to take the option of a peaceful relationship with Eritrea, although the conflict with Eritrea is one of the most complex crises experienced by the Ethiopian state in the past years. In June 2018, it accepted the full implementation of the Algiers Agreement and the final decision of the Ethiopian-Eritrean Boundary Commission (EEBC) signed in April 2002. The new Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed said in a formal address to parliament “that death can not be inherited for future generations, The Ethiopian-Eritrean war is the worst war History”. In this conflict the parties wasted money in arming instead of allocating them to farmers and developing the population of the region in both countries.
Ethiopia is gradually abandoning its previous policies with its neighbors and starting a long-term strategy to cooperate with East African countries. It is aiming at becoming a middle-income country on the one hand, and on the other hand a country with regional influence in Africa.
United Arab Emirates Entry:
Regional and international competition has increased over Ethiopia in recent years. This is especially evident in the Gulf crisis escalation as relations with Egypt are strained due to the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam. Saudi Arabia and the UAE, in particular, have begun a new approach to the concept of national and regional security by examining the seriousness of Ethiopia’s transformations and intentions. The attempt is to restructure relations with it within the framework of a comprehensive view of the interests map. This is especially in lieu of the escalated external security threats to the region and the Arab world.
The initiative came from the United Arab Emirates as surprise visit from the powerful Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi, Mohammed bin Zayed, to Addis Ababa. It focused on strengthening the friendship, cooperation and strategic partnership between the two countries and expanding the UAE’s investments in Ethiopia. It further came with the signing of seven agreements worth three billion dollars. One of which came as an effort to promote monetary stability by putting a deposit of one billion dollars in the Central Bank of Ethiopia to ease the shortage of foreign currency. It should be noted that the process of liberating the Yemeni port of Hodeidah from the grip of the Huthi militias, coincided with this visit. This was questionable about the understandings that took place between the two countries, especially that Ethiopia is close to Bab al-Mandab (is a strait located between Yemen on the Arabian Peninsula, and Djibouti and Eritrea in the Horn of Africa).
It is noteworthy that the UAE’s entry into the transformation in Ethiopia was through the visit of Mohammed bin Zayed to Addis Ababa. It was preceded by secret diplomatic ties with Abu Dhabi, which resulted in a very important breakthrough in the Ethiopian-Egyptian relations, and is the first of its kind in years.
When Abiy Ahmed went to Cairo, he spoke in a conciliatory language contrary to the rhetoric of escalation. This changed the political scene between the two countries over the past years, against the backdrop of the Renaissance Dam of Ethiopia. The sources said that the meeting established an openness to the Egyptian demands on its share in the Nile River water, especially with regard to the filling period of the dam. The Egyptian side demanded an increase in the number of years of filling the dam to be at least five to seven years.
In addition, new approaches to resolving the crisis are based on providing great economic and commercial incentives from the Gulf and Egyptian sides. The UAE will increase its investment in the tourism, agriculture and energy sectors. Egypt is offering a package of investments such as the establishment of an Egyptian industrial free zone in Ethiopia. There is an agreement to expand the work of the Arab Contractors Company and the Swedish Cables Company, both of which are in the field of construction and contracting.
The move of the Gulf and Egypt towards the understandings with the new Ethiopian government, after a period of tension with the government of Haili Miriam DiSalleen. It shows a distinction between the conflicting interests between the axis and the various interests of Turkey – Iran – Qatar – Israel, and relations with the neighboring Arab countries which were deeply conflicted over the Al Nahda Dam.
Indicators and implications:
The new changes and transformations cannot be realized immediately from internal and external power relations. It is not east to predict the success or failure of these policies, but instead to try to deduce the fate of the Ethiopian state itself. Since Abiy Ahmed’s arrival to the government in March, he has been sweeping the foundations of the Ethiopian state since the beginning of Mehlis Zenawi’s 1991 rule, which was complemented by Haile Meriam Desaline until his fall in February.
Within three months, Ethiopia witnessed a large wave of dismissals of senior military and security officials affiliated with the former regime. As well as taking democratic steps to absorb the opposition, stop arbitrary arrests, and settle disputes with neighboring countries, especially Eritrea. It is worth noting that all these measures are carried out without a solid ground on which Abiy Ahmed is based. The deep state, established over a period of about three decades, will not collapse in three months. The former regime was in control of the joints of the Ethiopian state, and has its followers in every place that conforms to its orientations and beneficiaries of its existence.
Abiy Ahmed’s assassination attempt on June 23 can be read as a strong message from the former regime. Those are the reverse forces that have been affected by reforms in the political and economic system, and liberalization of the market. The former regime has benefited from bureaucracy and corruption of power and control as a minority in all parts of the country The assassination attempt on the difficulty and risks of transformation in this pivotal country, as well as the capture of the Arab side of the importance of the arrival of a popular figure of the type of Abiy Ahmed.
The decisive factor in the continuation of the policies adopted by Abiy Ahmed is the degree to which he achieves the balance of power that has historically existed among the elite of the Tigray. So as to ensure their loyalty and not attempt to overthrow him. However, the continuation of the situation in this way, may lead to an attempt to pay attention to the new trends and rules in place to overthrow the government and restore the status quo.
The other scenario, the unifying of the unified federal state among the peoples of Ethiopia, which may carry the risk of chaos and instability. This leads to the request of one of the region’s independence from the central state, where the Constitution states that the same can claim any territory to obtain the right to self-determination. Yet, the difficulty of this scenario is that the Tigray does not exceed 6% of the population, so it is not in his interest to be independent from the state.
Finally, overcoming the chronic crises in Ethiopia depends on the extent to which the new government can lay down the rules of full citizenship and offer temptations to all regions to maintain state cohesion, and stop attempts to topple the government. It also depends on the volume of support and foreign investment aimed at continuing the implementation of political and economic reforms which were promised by Abiy Ahmed.
http://www.arabprogress.org/2018/06/28/%D9%85%D8%AD%D8%AF%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A3%D9%85%D9%86-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D9%88%D9%85%D9%89-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%A8%D9%89-%D9%88-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%B3-%D8%B9/